Timeless: Century-historical Arguments towards Gun handle legal guidelines are just as legitimate nowadays

◀previous publish

H.L. Mencken (1880-1956) changed into the most influential newspaperman of his period and a prolific writer of iconoclastic books and essays. here is reprinted from The evening sun of Baltimore, November 30, 1925. Copyright 1925 by using The night sun. Republication devoid of credit no longer authorised.


The eminent Nation publicizes with savour “the corporation of a countrywide committee of one hundred to set off Congress to restrict the inter-State traffic in revolvers,” and offers the pious judgement that it’s “a step ahead.” “Crime records,” it looks, “show that ninety% of the murders that take area are committed by the use of the pistol, and every 12 months there are a whole bunch of cases of unintended homicide as a result of a person did not recognize that his revolver became loaded.”

the new legislations—or is it to be a constitutional change?—will get rid of all that. “It should not effortless,” of path, “to draw a legislation that allows you to let exceptions for public officers and financial institution guards”—to assert nothing of Prohibition agents and other such legalized murderers. “however soon even these officials may additionally get on devoid of revolvers.”

more than once, in this area, I have lavished excessive compliment upon the Nation. All that praise has been deserved, and i am by no ability disposed to move lower back on it. The Nation is one of the few honest and clever periodicals ever posted within the u.s.. It stands clear of legitimate buncombe; it prints a week a great mass of news that the newspapers appear to pass over; it interprets that information with a freedom and a sagacity that few newspaper editors can even so a whole lot as think about.

If it shut up shop then the country would plunge just about unchallenged into the bottom depths of Coolidgism, Rotarianism, Stantaquaism and other such bilge. It has been, for a decade previous, the executive consolation of the small and forlorn minority of civilized americans.

however the Nation, in its days, has been a Liberal organ, and its historical follies die complicated. Ever and anon, in the middle of its most eloquent and helpful pleas for Liberty, its eye wanders weakly towards law. At such moments the historic lust to carry ‘em up overcomes it, and it makes a brilliant and melodramatic ass of itself. this type of moment was upon it when it printed the paragraph that I even have quoted. Into that paragraph—of not over 200 words—it packed as an awful lot maudlin and nonsensical blather, as a great deal idiotic reasoning and banal moralizing, as Dr. Coolidge receives into a speech of two hours’ length.


the new law that it encouraged, certainly, is among the most absurd specimens of jackass legislations ever heard of, even in this paradise of legislative donkeyism. Its single and sole impact would be to magnify tremendously all of the evils it proposes to put down. it might not take pistols out of the hands of rogues and fools; it would without difficulty take them out of the palms of sincere men.

The gunman today has tremendous benefits far and wide. He has artillery in his pocket, and he might also assume that, within the big cities, at least two-thirds of his prospective victims are unarmed. but when the Nation’s proposed legislation (or change) were handed and enforced, he might assume safely that all of them have been unarmed.

right here I do not bask in theory. The difficult statistics are publicly on reveal in big apple State, where a legislation of exactly the same tenor is already on the books—the so-known as Sullivan legislation. as a way to get it there, of course, the 2nd change needed to be severely strained, but the uplifters recommended the straining unanimously, and to the tune of loud hosannas, and the courts, as average, were inclined to signal on the dotted line.

it is now a dreadful prison in manhattan to “have or possess” a pistol. even if one continues it locked in a bureau drawer at domestic, one could be despatched to the hoosegow for ten years. extra, men who’ve carried out no greater are often got rid of.

The police officers, suspecting a man, say, of political heresy, raid his condo and search for copies of the Nation. They locate none, and are thus baffled—however at the bottom of a trunk they do find a rusted and battered revolver. So he goes on trial for violating the Sullivan legislations, and is presently being psychoanalyzed with the aid of the uplifters at Sing Sing.

With what result? With the time-honored influence that long island, even more than Chicago, is the heaven of footpads, hijackers, gunmen and all other such armed thugs. Their palms upon their pistols, they comprehend that they’re protected.

now not one citizen out of a hundred that they address is armed for getting a license to hold a revolver is a tricky enterprise, and carrying one with out it’s extra unhealthy than submitting to theft. So the gunmen flourish and give humble due to God. just like the bootleggers, they’re scorching and unanimous for law Enforcement.


To all this, of course, the uplifters have a capable reply. (At having equipped answers, certainly, they at all times shine!) The long island thugs, they say, are armed to the enamel as a result of New Jersey and Connecticut lack Sullivan laws. When one of them needs a revolver all he has to do is to go the river or take a brief trolley go back and forth. Or, to quote the Nation, he can also “comfortably remit to one of the most big organizations which promote the sale of their weapons by way of mail.”

The remedy is the standard dose: extra law. Congress is besought to “restrict the inter-State traffic in revolvers, above all to bar them from the mails.”

it is all very well-known, and intensely miserable. locate me a person so enormous an imbecile that he severely believes that this prohibition would work. What would turn into of the thousands and thousands of revolvers already within the arms of the American individuals if now not in manhattan, then as a minimum in every single place else? (I own two and my brother owns at least a dozen, notwithstanding neither of us has fired one considering that the shut of the freedom personal loan drives.)

Would the cops without delay confiscate this vast stock, or would it not are likely to concentrate in the palms of the crook courses? if they attempted confiscation, how would they get my two revolvers—lawfully bought and possessed—without breaking into my condo? Would I look ahead to them docilely—or would I promote out, in anticipation, to the closest pistol bootlegger?

the first effect of the enactment of the sort of legislation, without doubt, can be to make the market price of all small hands upward thrust sharply. A pistol which is now value, 2d-hand, in all probability $2, would right now attain a worth of $10 and even $20. this is not theorizing; we now have had a lot of experience with gin.

smartly, imagining such fees to succeed, would the generality of men quit their weapons to the Polizei, or would they promote them to the bootleggers? And in the event that they sold them to the bootleggers, what would turn into of them in the end: would they fall into the palms of sincere men or into the arms of rogues?


however the gunmen, I take it, would now not undergo from the high charge of artillery for long. The second the rate obtained in fact beautiful, the cops themselves would start to sell their pistols, and with them the entire corps of Prohibition blacklegs, inner most detectives, deputy sheriffs, and other such scoundrels. And smuggling, as in the case of alcoholic beverages, would turn into an organized business, massive in scale and lordly in profits.

imagine the components that could pour over the long Canadian and Mexican borders! And into every port on each incoming ship!

definitely, the historical past of the try to implement Prohibition may still give even uplifters pause. A case of whisky is a bulky object. It must be transported on a truck. It can not be disguised. Yet in each American city nowadays a case of whisky can be bought just about as without difficulty as a pair of shoes regardless of all of the armed guards alongside the Canadian border, and all of the protect ships off the ports, and all the raiding, snooping and murdering all over else. accordingly the camel gets in and yet the proponents of the brand new anti-pistol legislations tell us that they’re going to catch the gnat! Go whisper it to the Marines!

this kind of law, certainly, would quite simply make gun-toting swagger and classy, as Prohibition has made guzzling swagger and classy. When i was an adolescent there were no Prohibition agents; hence I by no means so much as drank a tumbler of beer until i was almost 19. these days, legislations Enforcement is the eighth sacrament and the Methodist Board of Temperance, Prohibition and Public Morals through itself authority for the sad news that the younger of the land are filled with gin.

I be aware, in my formative years, a time when the police officers tried to limit the game of catty. at once every boy in Baltimore consecrated his entire time and energy to it. eventually, the police officers gave up their crusade. practically instantly catty disappeared.


The true victim of ethical legislations is always the honest, legislations-abiding, well-that means citizen—what the late William Graham summer season known as the Forgotten Man. Prohibition makes it unimaginable for him to take a innocent drink, cheaply and in a good manner.

within the equal manner the Harrison Act places heavy burdens upon the health care professional who has want of prescribing narcotic medicine for a affected person, honestly and for good ends. however the drunkard nonetheless gets all of the alcohol that he can grasp, and the drug addict continues to be crammed with morphine and cocaine.

by using exactly the identical route the Nation’s new legislations would deprive the legit citizen of the hands he needs for insurance plan, and hand them over to the rogues that he needs insurance plan towards.

Ten or fifteen years in the past there turned into a pandemic of suicide through bichloride of mercury pills. without delay the uplifters proposed laws forbidding their sale, and such laws are actually in drive in lots of States, including long island. The consequences are classical. a new Yorker, desiring to lay in an antiseptic for family unit use, is disadvantaged of the least expensive, most handy and most helpful. And the suicide price in long island, as in different places, is still regularly rising.

this article become in the beginning published on fee.org. read the long-established article.

◀outdated submit